Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Florida - West Coast

The Bridges of Madison County
Manatee Players
Review by William S. Oser | Season Schedule

Also see Bill's review of Synergy

Dianne Dawson and Charles Dugan
Photo by Janet Poelsma
Manatee Players presents The Bridges of Madison County, music and lyrics by Jason Robert Brown, book by Marsha Norman. The musical is based on the hugely successful novel by Robert James Waller and the almost equally successful film staring Clint Eastwood and Meryl Streep. Honestly, I could never bring myself to read the book, as it seemed to be not my cup of tea, and the movie also did not fit me.

Hearing the Broadway cast album, I felt something for Francesca and Robert for the first time. Jason Robert Brown's music elevates the emotional arc to an almost operatic level. Unfortunately, the adaptation is very uneven: Whenever the two leading characters are front and center, the musical is at its best; whenever the townsfolk are around, mostly to open up the story, things go awry. The problem is a serious one, enough to dull the impact of some gorgeous writing, perhaps the finest thing Brown has ever produced. It might work well as a song cycle of the material for Robert and Francesca.

Manatee Players offers a production that is almost as vividly sung as was the Broadway version, which was headed by Kelli O'Hara and Steven Pasquale. Dianne Dawson is simply magnificent as Francesca. I have noticed that some of our finest community theater actors are incredibly versatile, playing roles that their Broadway counterparts wouldn't dare. Last year in this same slot, Ms. Dawson trotted the boards with an awesome Florence in Chess, the year before she played The Baker's Wife in Into the Woods. I have previously seen her as Marion Paroo in The Music Man, Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd, and Dot in Sunday in the Park with George as well as other roles opposite her equally talented husband, Steve. I defy the extremely gifted Kelli O'Hara to take a whack at Mrs. Lovett or Florence.

Charles Dugan is making his Manatee Players debut, although he is widely known as a performer in the Tampa area. He is a tenor, maybe not an operatic tenor, but clearly a tenor, in a part conceived for a baritone. Unless my ears deceived me, they transposed a couple of his solo numbers up to accommodate the beauty of his high range. I prefer the slightly more masculine sound of a baritone, but with singing this glorious no one should quibble. He is quite the hunk, making it totally believable that Francesca could fall for him. Music direction is by Thomas D. Guthrie who gives these two, and the rest of the cast, superb support from the pit.

Cory Woomert turns in another in a series of fine performances, this time as Francesca's husband Bud. Although written for the considerable talents of Hunter Foster, the role is uninteresting, and I can't imagine anyone really scoring with it. Griffyn Holcomb and Catherine Austin are Francesca and Bud's children, David Addis and Victoria Gross are neighbors Charlie and Marge, Michelle Anaya plays three different roles, but all these fine performers are up against material that falls flat. Carla Austin, Brian Craft, Brenna Griffith, Bradley Keville, Cody Longhitano, Michelle Northcraft and Lindsay Yarbrough are the hardworking ensemble.

Kathy Pingel, director, along with choreographer Vanessa Russo, and aided by the technical talents of Donna Buckalter (scenic design), Ryan E. Finzelber (lighting design) and Becky Evans (costume design) has put together a production that is as fluid as could be. Sound design by Tom Sell is perfect, I was able to understand almost every word, not always the case in this theater which has sonic gremlins lurking about.

I am thrilled that Manatee Players has brought The Bridges of Madison County to this area in such a superb production. This is some of the finest work I have seen on a community theater stage in a very long time. If the whole of The Bridges of Madison County were stronger, I believe this would be the non-professional production of the year that everyone would remember. I think that lovers of musical theater are going to want to see this production.

Manatee Players presents The Bridges of Madison County at Manatee Center for the Performing Arts through February 26, 2017, at 502 3rd Ave W., Bradenton; 941-748-0111,

Francesca Johnson: Dianne Dawson
Robert Kincaid: Charles Dugan
Bud Johnson: Cory WoomertCharlie: David Addis
Marge: Victoria Gross
Chiara/Marian: Michelle Anaya
Michael Johnson: Griffyn Holcomb
Carolyn Johnson: Catherine Austin
State Fair Singer: Michelle Anaya
Ginny: Lindsay Yarbrough
Paolo/Jeff: Cody Longhitano
Waitress: Carla Austin
Bartender: Bradley Keville
Ensemble: Carla Austin, Brian Craft, Brenna Griffith, Bradley Keville, Cody Longhitano, Michelle Northcraft, Lindsay Yarbrough

Conductor/Keyboard: Thomas D. Guthrie
Second Keyboard: Michael Stewart
Guitar: Tony Rizzo
Violin: A.J. Vaughan
Percussion: John Januszewski

Directed by Kathy Pingel
Choreographed by Vanessa Russo
Music Directed by Thomas D. Guthrie
Scenic Design by Donna Buckalter
Lighting Design by Ryan E. FinzelberCostume Design by Becky Evans
Stage Managed by Tiffany Smith
Sound Design by Tom Sell

Privacy Policy